The Anasazi Collapse and Climate Change
The term ‘’Anasazi’’ also called the ‘’Ancestral Puebloans’’, were the first human occupants of Chaco Canyon, located in the southwestern United States, arrived around 10,000 BC. The Ancestral Puebloans began their occupation in the Archaic period (3000–100 BC) and continued until around 1300 AD. Chaco Canyon became a center of social complexity, featuring hierarchical society, intensive agriculture, ceremonial activities, and long-distance trade. A summary of Anasazi’s early and pueblo periods:
Early Period
o Began as nomadic hunter-gatherers
o Gradually transitioned to a more sedentary lifestyle (cultivating corn, beans, and squash)
Pueblo I
o Building above-ground stone and adobe dwellings (Pueblos)
o Advanced agricultural techniques, including irrigation and dry farming
Pueblo II
o Significant population growth
o The construction of large and multi-storied buildings (Chaco Canyon)
Pueblo III
o Building cliff dwellings (Mesa Verde)
o Increasing social and environmental challenges (droughts and resource depletion)
Pueblo IV
o The Anasazi migrated to areas with more reliable water sources
o Established new communities along the Rio Grande and parts of Arizona
One of the primary factors identified for the Anasazi’s collapse is climate change, specifically a series of prolonged droughts, such as the Great Drought from 1276 to 1299 AD. The Chaco Canyon area features a diverse environment with varying elevations and vegetation, including desert shrub-grasslands, riparian trees, and high-altitude forests. Climate history shows periods of increasing aridity, stable mesic conditions, and notable droughts. These droughts severely impacted agricultural yields, particularly corn, which was a staple of their diet. The resulting food shortages likely led to nutritional deficiencies and increased competition for scarce resources.
The shift from foraging to farming represented a major transformation in the region's subsistence strategies. The adoption of agriculture brought about a new way of life, as communities began to rely on cultivated crops rather than solely on wild resources. The introduction of corn, beans, and squash not only provided a stable food source but also brought about agricultural complementarity. Beans, with their nitrogen-fixing bacteria, enhanced soil fertility, benefiting the growth of corn and squash. This interdependence between crops contributed to the sustainability of agricultural practices, allowing for more intensive land use and supporting larger populations.
Before 600 BC, the region was characterized by a pinyon-juniper woodland, indicative of a stable and rich environment (See Fig 4. Stratigraphic profile of Operation). This ecosystem supported a diverse range of flora and fauna, creating a balanced and productive habitat. The prevalence of juniper pollen during this period reflects the dominance of juniper trees in the landscape, suggesting a long-standing ecological equilibrium. However, significant environmental changes began to unfold shortly after 600 BC, marked by a sharp decline in juniper pollen levels. This decline suggests a disruption in the region's stability, hinting at changing climatic conditions, human activities, or a combination of both.
By 1100 AD, the situation had deteriorated further, with juniper pollen levels plummeting to a mere 2%. This dramatic reduction indicates the near-complete disappearance of juniper trees in the canyon, a stark contrast to the previously juniper-dominated woodland. This decline coincided with notable periods of erosion and sediment aggradation, underscoring a correlation between vegetation loss and soil instability. The removal of juniper trees likely exacerbated soil erosion, as their roots no longer anchored the soil, leading to increased sediment displacement and landscape degradation.
During this period, fluctuations in pine pollen levels were observed, suggesting varying uses and possible external influences on the canyon's ecosystem. The presence and abundance of pine pollen may have been affected by different factors such as climate variations, human interventions, or ecological succession. Concurrently, greasewood and willow pollen trends mirrored those of juniper, further reflecting the broader ecological shifts. These changes in vegetation composition indicate a significant transformation in the regional ecology, likely driven by a combination of natural and anthropogenic factors.
In addition to environmental stressors, social factors played a significant role. Population growth and resource competition led to conflicts and warfare. Archaeological evidence from sites like Sand Canyon Pueblo indicates that violence, including evidence of cannibalism, was present during the period of decline. This suggests that internal strife and external threats exacerbated the difficulties faced by the Anasazi.
In summary, the Anasazi’ use of local resources for fuel and timber led to extensive depletion, contributing to environmental degradation and making it harder to recover from climatic and social stresses. The combination of these factors forced the Anasazi to abandon their settlements in search of more hospitable environments, marking the end of their presence in regions such as Chaco Canyon and Mesa Verde.
Ecosystem impacts by the Ancestral Puebloans of Chaco Canyon, New Mexico, USA
Dynamics in Human and Primate Societies Agent-Based Modeling of Social and Spatial Processes
If you like my blog posts, please share, subscribe and consider Buying Me a Coffee or supporting me on Patreon.